Tactical

Why One Shooting Was Clear Self-Defense and the Other Barely Was

November 17, 2026

Carrying a gun doesn't automatically make a shooting legal, and two recent self-defense cases show why the details of how a confrontation starts and unfolds matter as much as the outcome.

Snapshot

Bearing Arms writer Cam Edwards looks at two fatal defensive shootings, one in Detroit and one in Missouri, with different legal results. One involved a clear ambush with no time to retreat, the other a road-rage dispute where both men had chances to walk away before anyone drew a gun.

Key points

  • Detroit carjacking: Two suspects forced a man and a companion to their knees during a carjacking, and one suspect ordered the other to shoot them. The intended victim drew his own gun first, killing one suspect and wounding the other, a case Edwards calls clear-cut self-defense.
  • Missouri road rage: Vance Townes honked and yelled at a driver for going too slowly, then followed him into a parking lot after both pulled into it. Townes got out holding a handgun and approached the other vehicle before its driver fired five shots and killed him.
  • No charges filed: St. Louis prosecutors declined to charge the Honda driver, citing insurmountable self-defense elements. Attorney Jay Kanzler noted that a driver confronted by an armed person approaching his vehicle has a clear legal right to shoot under state law.
  • Bad decisions, lawful outcome: Edwards argues the Honda driver never should have pulled into that lot with his family in the car, and Townes should have driven off instead of confronting him with a gun. Even so, once Townes approached armed, the driver's right to defend his family stood.
  • The lesson: Both cases turned on who created the deadly threat and whether retreat was possible, not simply on who was carrying.

Quick take

These cases are a reminder that legal justification hinges on timing and who escalates first. Avoiding a confrontation, or disengaging when you still can, protects you legally as much as it does physically.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com